Contemporary Blog

BlogBud [SM]

Click Here to Visit This Writer's Site

[Last 100 Blogs] [Blog Search] [Contact Us] [FREE Site] [Home] [Writers] [Login]

  Search For A Writer

  Search For Blog

Last Posts
  1. Dreams : Stargazer November 13 to 15 2020

  2. Dreams : Stargazer November 10 to 12 2020

  3. War and Anthropology

  4. Dreams : Stargazer November 7 to 9 2020

  5. Dreams : Stargazer November 4 to 6 2020

  6. Dreams : Stargazer November 1 to 3 2020

  7. Dreams : Stargazer October 29 to 31 2020

  8. Dreams : Stargazer October 26 to 28 2020

  9. Dreams : Stargazer October 23 to 25 2020

  10. Dreams : Stargazer October 20 to 22 2020

  11. We are one human race in a troubled world.

  12. Notes on the Protestant Reformation

  13. Dreams : Stargazer October 17 to 19 2020

  14. Dreams : Stargazer October 14 to 16 2020

  15. Dreams : Stargazer October 11 to 13 2020

  16. Dreams :Stargazer October 8 to 10 2020

  17. Dreams : Stargazer October 5 to 7 2020

  18. Dreams : Stargazer October 2 to 4 2020

  19. Dreams : Stargazer September 29 to October 1 2020

  20. Dreams : Stargazer September 26 to 28 2020

  21. Dreams : Stargazer September 23 to 25 2020

  22. Dreams : Stargazer September 20 to 22 2020

  23. DREAMS : Stargazer September 17 to 19 2020

  24. Dreams : Stargazer September 14 to 16 2020

  25. Dreams : Stargazer September 11 to 13 2020

  26. Dreams : Stargazer September 8 to 10 2020

  27. Dreams : Stargazer September 5 to 7 2020

  28. Dreams : Stargazer September 2 to 4 2020

  29. Dreams : Stargazer August 30 To September 1 2020

  30. Rabindranath Tagore

  31. Dreams : Stargazer August 27 to 29 2020

  32. Dreams : Stargazer August 24 to 26 2020

  33. Dreams : Stargazer August 21 to 23 2020

  34. Dreams : Stargazer August 18 to 20 2020

  35. Dreams : Stargazer August 15 to 17 2020

  36. Dreams : Stargazer August 12 to 14 2020

  37. Dreams : Stargazer August 9 to 11 2020

  38. Dreams : Stargazer August 6 to 8 2020

  39. Dreams : Stargazer August 3 to 5 2020

War and Anthropology

Critical Review #1 Prepared by Curran Jeffery
Anthropology and Counterinsurgency:
The Strange Story of their Curious Relationship
Montgomery McFate, J.D., Ph.D.
March-April 2005, Military Review,

Scholarship and war are strange bedfellows. But the end of World War II brought them together to prevent what could have been even a bloodier conclusion to tragedy than we already had. The work of anthropologist Ruth Benedict (The Chrysanthemum and the Sword) convinced The White House to leave the Emperor out of the demands for surrender. In the Mythos of the Japanese people, the Emperor was sacred and absolutely to be obeyed. The fact that he was treated with respect and accepted surrender made it possible for the Japanese people to not fight to the last one standing which is what the American High Commanded had expected despite Hiroshima. He was treated with respect (unlike Hitler and Mussolini) because FDR accepted Benedict’s insights into the Culture of Japan and saw them as a path to Peace.

Fast forward 30 years to America’s tragic failure in Viet Nam. Anthropologists had presented the military commanders the approach of “hearts and Minds.” Counter insurgency is not the same as traditional European war between industrialized nation states where the guy with the most guns wins. It’s about people living in their villages, dealing with outside forces they often don’t understand. Although many of the officers saw the wisdom of understanding the Vietnamese people, the high command continually opted for overwhelming force. You’re using helicopters and tanks against an unseen enemy fighting a tribal war.

These two examples illustrate the conflict between traditional ideas of military strategy and the reality of counterinsurgency where cultural and religious values come into play. It highlights the dilemma of scholars who must deal with the possibility of their work being used to harm the people they researched. They must also deal with the possibility that with holding their research can make a bad situation even worse. There is often not an easy answer.

Dr. Montgomery McFate is well positioned to do applied anthropology in military and national security affairs. After UC Berkley, Harvard, and Yale, she earned her Ph.D in 1994. After the events of 9-11, she saw as her mission to convince the American military establishment the need to have a cultural understanding of the adversary. She is on the faculty of the US Navel War College. She is very controversial. Many anthropologists frown on her attempts to work with the military as a return to “colonial anthropology.”

Her point is well made: partially by tragic hindsight. If the American military brass had understood that the conflict in Viet Nam was not a military battle between super powers but a civil, political, economic conflict between local groups within Vietnamese society, we might have been able to broker a peace rather than create a blood bath. The Vietnamese people didn’t want any outside power to determine their fate. The Taoist principle of Universal Harmony and the need to return to it was shared by all Vietnamese. This could have been used to find a way forward. Instead, the American Military replaced the French in support of a Roman Catholic ruling elite that oppressed the Buddhist majority. We could have been seen as liberators but instead we became just another foreign oppressor who had to be driven out of the country just like the Chinese, the Japanese and the French.

Insight and wisdom can come from many sources. Cultural anthropology has yet to be overused. In today’s flashpoints, the Middle East, South Asia, and Central Africa, the conflicts often originate in conflicting religious loyalties. Yet there have been times when these same groups lived together in at least tolerance if not peace. What makes the difference? Can an era of peaceful co-existence be created and maintained? Is there any common ground? After all, Islam and Christianity share Jesus. These are questions that need to be asked, worked with, and answers found. For example, archeologists have established that the ancestors of the Jewish people are also the ancestors of the Palestinians. The adversaries are cousins.

Comment Here

Excellent Good Average Poor Bad


Email Address


Sign In
Privacy Policy
Report A Site!
Last 100 Blogs
Get Your Free Site Project Ideas for kids,
Halloween, Christmas
and More

Meet Other Writers
poetry4812 sweethumm joyitadarling
mvm judyarlinepuckett smallsteps

***Remove this feature
along with ads from curran

Get your free blog site Now!
Terms of Use

[Last 100 Blogs] [Blog Search] [Contact Us] [FREE Site] [Home] [Writers] [Login]

Remove ads from curran -  Just $2 a month [ Click Here ]
Remove ads from curran -  Just $1 a month with a yearly subscription [ Click Here ]